What should I play next

Ask for the shape of the challenge.

Not “something hard” — something that leans on the axes you want leant on and stays out of the way everywhere else. Demanding on strategy, forgiving on execution, under twenty hours. Everything below is scored through your own calibration, so “demanding” means demanding for you.

You have not calibrated, so this is matching against an average player. It still works; it is just not about you yet.

Calibrate
Or from something you finished

Sign in and this can read the ask out of a game you have already beaten.

Execution
Reaction
Strategy
Puzzle
Grind
Punishment
Learning Curve
Obscurity
Clear

Read out of Spelunky 2

Nearest fingerprints in the catalogue. The same demands, a different game.

Noita

2020 · Nolla Games · ~30h

8.0NIGHTMARE

Every pixel is simulated, so every run is one wand mistake away from killing you instantly. Wand editing is a programming language the game never teaches.

UnratedOBS 9.5PUN 9.2CRV 8.8
EXE 6.5REA 7.0PUZ 4.0GRD 3.5PUN 9.2CRV 8.8OBS 9.5

Elden Ring Nightreign

2025 · FromSoftware · ~40h

6.9BRUTAL

Three in-game days on a shrinking map, so the usual answer to a FromSoftware wall — go somewhere else and come back stronger — is the one thing the clock will not sell you.

UnratedREA 7.8CRV 7.8PUN 7.2
EXE 6.9REA 7.8PUZ 1.5PUN 7.2CRV 7.8OBS 6.9GRD 4.5 — you asked for forgiving

Enter the Gungeon

2016 · Dodge Roll · ~30h

7.0BRUTAL

A bullet hell with a generous dodge roll and completely ungenerous boss patterns. The unlock grind is doing double duty as the difficulty curve.

UnratedREA 8.2EXE 7.4OBS 7.2
EXE 7.4REA 8.2PUZ 1.5PUN 7.0CRV 6.5OBS 7.2GRD 4.5 — you asked for forgiving

Rain World

2017 · Videocult · ~40h

7.8NIGHTMARE

A simulated ecosystem that has no interest in being fair. Movement takes twenty hours to feel deliberate, the rain cycle takes back anything you did not bank, and nothing is explained at any point.

UnratedOBS 9.6CRV 9.2PUN 8.0
GRD 3.8PUN 8.0CRV 9.2OBS 9.6EXE 5.9 — you asked for demandingREA 5.8 — you asked for demandingPUZ 4.5 — you asked for forgiving

Ninja Gaiden Black

2005 · Team NINJA · ~20h

7.3BRUTAL

Enemies act during your recovery frames and refuse to wait their turn. The famous difficulty is the ordinary encounters, not the bosses.

UnratedCRV 8.8REA 8.0EXE 7.8
EXE 7.8REA 8.0PUZ 1.0GRD 2.8PUN 7.5CRV 8.8OBS 6.0

Demon’s Souls

2020 · Bluepoint Games · ~30h

6.7PUNISHING

The combat is the gentlest in the family and the systems are the cruellest — dying moves you to soul form at half health, and the game never says so.

UnratedOBS 8.4PUN 7.4CRV 6.8Not on your platforms
PUZ 1.5PUN 7.4CRV 6.8OBS 8.4EXE 4.8 — you asked for demandingREA 5.8 — you asked for demandingGRD 4.8 — you asked for forgiving

Dark Souls

2011 · FromSoftware · ~45h

6.5PUNISHING

The difficulty is mostly geography — knowing which door to take is worth more than any weapon in the game.

UnratedOBS 7.8CRV 7.5PUN 6.8
REA 6.2PUZ 1.8PUN 6.8CRV 7.5OBS 7.8EXE 5.3 — you asked for demandingGRD 4.5 — you asked for forgiving

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

2015 · FromSoftware · ~50h

6.6PUNISHING

The one that attacks your resources rather than your reflexes — your maximum health falls every time you die, and the ambushes are designed around you not knowing they are there.

UnratedOBS 7.6PUN 7.4CRV 6.6
PUZ 1.6PUN 7.4CRV 6.6OBS 7.6EXE 5.3 — you asked for demandingREA 5.8 — you asked for demandingGRD 6.0 — you asked for forgiving

Hollow Knight: Silksong

2025 · Team Cherry · ~40h

6.5PUNISHING

Faster than Hollow Knight and less forgiving with it. Enemies crowd, healing is a commitment rather than a pause, and the early bosses assume reflexes the first game spent thirty hours building.

UnratedEXE 7.4OBS 7.5CRV 7.4
EXE 7.4REA 7.2PUZ 2.2GRD 3.5PUN 6.2CRV 7.4OBS 7.5

The Surge

2017 · Deck13 Interactive · ~20h

5.9STEEP

You choose which limb to cut off, which means every fight is a decision about what you want to be wearing afterwards rather than only about surviving it.

UnratedREA 6.5PUN 6.5OBS 6.5
EXE 6.2REA 6.5PUZ 1.8PUN 6.5CRV 6.0OBS 6.5GRD 4.5 — you asked for forgiving